Even as paid content continues to gain momentum in media boardrooms and on the news industry conference circuit (witness ridiculous posts like this one, claiming ‘consensus’ on the matter), those with practical experience play a necessary and realistic role of debunker.
John Gruber of Daring Fireball weighs in with Pay Walls, taking apart screenwriter David Simon’s call for immediate subscription-only services for the two biggest American newspaper sites. Simon’s a great writer, his HBO series The Wire ranks in my arena as one of the best ever on television. But like so many professional writers who believe the newspaper business is only about journalism , Simon falls short on discovering the more fundamental issues. Gruber’s summary hits one of those issues good and hard:
The primary problem with newspaper companies isn’t their revenue. It’s the size and scope of their operations.
Robert Ivan at Metaprinter, in concurring with Gruber…
Pre-internet, general interest newspapers made money because they were effective advertising solutions on a cheap and convenient distribution platform, not because they won Pulitzer Prizes.
Ivan also points to more viable solutions for newspapers, essentially the offering of creative services and marketing for the greater internet.
This is precisely the position I’ve begun to take in recent months, in my own business meetings with those who care to listen, or just those who get stuck in a room with me. Accepting the premise that (A) paid content will only work in very unique niches, and even then only to a certain degree, and (B) online ad placements will only cover a part of the revenue needs for even the leanest of news site staffs, then we must move along to (C) which is, other stuff to pay the bills. And in the newspaper/media setting, the best use of (C) might well be a hybrid of agency work and nimble online marketing for the many small and medium-sized businesses with whom we already have a working relationship. That’s new territory, especially in a business where we’ve traditionally given away creative production of ads as part of the placement cost. New territory, one way or another, is certainly where we’re headed.